Posted on

MSR Carbon Reflex Fast and Light Tent Body Review

MSR has a new class of double-wall inner tents called fast and light tent “bodies” which are inner tents without any mesh, designed to reduce gear weight and provide more rain-splatter protection than pitching the fly in a fast and light footprint configuration. Unlike footprints, the tent bodies have bathtub floors and sidewalls just like a regular inner tent. They are not footprints themselves and provide no added durability beyond a regular inner tent floor.t

The MSR Freelite 2 Tent hangs from an external exoskeleton frame with a crossbar that helps keep the side walls nearly vertical.
The MSR Freelite 2 Tent has Y-shaped hubs at both ends. 

MSR makes these new tent bodies for their Hubba, Hubba Tour, Freelite, Carbon Reflex model tents. The tent bodies work best with the Hubba, Freelite, and Hubba Tour models which have Y-shaped end poles connected with a hub. The tent bodies have hooks that attach to the poles above the hubs, so they don’t slide down. Here’s a video that illustrates tent body setup with the hubbed pole architectures.

The MSR Carbon Reflex tents differ from the Hubba, Freelite, and Hubba Tour series because they don’t have hubbed end poles. They have a single pole that hooks into a grommet in the middle of the inner tent floor instead. This little detail isn’t documented anywhere and threw me for a loop when I tried to set the tent body up on a overnight trip. Consider this review a head-ups if you have a Carbon Reflex and have been considering this add-on.

The Carbon Reflex does not have a hubbed pole
The Carbon Reflex 1 does not have a hubbed pole, so there’s no attachment point to hold the end of the tent body up.

Instead, you need to first attach the pole to the rain fly using the velcro tabs that connect it to the pole in windy weather, exactly like you’re attach the Carbon Reflex 1 footprint if you were using the fast and light footprint setup instead. Continue by inserting the pole ends into the center body grommets on the tent body floor and stake out the rain fly corners. Next attach the tent body clips to the pole, above the velcro tabs, to hold the ends of the tent body up and create the bathtub floor sidewalls. The setup will look like this.

Carbon Reflex 1 Tent Body Setup. Photo courtesy MSR
Carbon Reflex 1 Tent Body Setup. Photo courtesy MSR

The resulting structure is somewhat cooler and better ventilated than using the regular inner tent because there’s no mesh. However, the “stand-up-ed-ness” of the tent body end walls is totally dependent on the velcro tabs inside fly and not on the hubbed Y pole architecture used by MSR’s other tents. It’s a much less resilient architecture because the velcro tabs are not nearly as strong as tent pole hubs.

How much of a weight savings is there? On the Carbon  Reflex 1, the weight savings of using the meshless tent body over a the regular inner tent is 2.6 ounces and costs $100, which I consider kind of expensive. The weight difference between a lighter weight footprint only-setup (no inner tent) and the tent body is 2.4 ounces.

Net Net, I’d give the Carbon Reflex 1 Tent Body a pass because it only provides a 2.6 ounce gear weight reduction over the regular tent. Carrying an additional 2.6 ounces isn’t going to slow you down very much on a backpacking trip and is easily compensated for by trimming other less expensive sources of gear or food weight. MSR’s new tent bodies probably provide a much larger weight reduction for their two-person and three-person variants, but it’s hard to know since MSR has done such a poor job at documenting the weight differences.

Note to MSR: Please publish a table showing the minimal trail weight for each tent, the weight of the regular inner tent, the weight of tent body, and the weight of the fast and light foot print for each model of tent for which the tent body is an option. 

The meshless MSR tent body provides storage and sidewalls
The meshless MSR tent body provides storage and sidewalls

Evaluation of the Tent Body Concept

While the tent body concept is attractive in theory, it’s really just an inner tent without any bug mesh and something you’ll may use infrequently. A much better solution would be to replace the Carbon Reflex’s inner tent altogether and sell the tent with an inner tent that has removable mesh panels. This kind of option is available in the modular four season backpacking hammocks hammocks made by Dream Hammock, Warbonnet, and DutchWare. If you don’t need the mesh, you simply remove it. This kind of enhanced inner tent would be easier to sell to consumers, easier to explain, differentiate MSR’s tents from competitors, and provide more value in your purchase. That’s my 2 cents.

Compare 3 Prices

Last updated: 2018-07-05 08:46:38 receives affiliate compensation from retailers that we link to if you make a purchase through them, at no additional cost to you. This helps to keep our content free and pays for our website hosting costs. Thank you for your support.

MSR provided a tent and tent body for this evaluation. Published 2018.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *